Friday, November 28, 2008

State court, or federal, for civil rights actions?

Did you see that two state court judges have now struck down the Florida statute banning adoption by lesbians and gay men? Very interesting. Makes me wonder if the folks in Florida ever bothered before with a suit to eliminate that ban in state court, or if they went directly to federal court, which in this instance proved to be a bust -- the 11th circuit court of appeals upheld the law a year or so ago. The US Supreme Court refused to hear the case.

This is an interesting phenomenon in its own right, but also as a contrast between the lesbian/gay/bisexual/transgender (LGBT) civil rights movement and the African American civil rights movement, which set the standard for civil rights movements in the United States and still impacts other movements, including the LGBT movement. For African Americans, federal court was the only place to go, because many state judges were openly racist and would never give black litigants a fair hearing. I recently interviewed a number of African American graduates of Emory law school. One woman told me of being in court and having the judge say to her "sit down, little girl" every time she tried to speak. He would only interact with the white prosecutor.

Some federal judges, by contrast, took civil rights cases, and the litigants who brought them, very seriously, producing a number of important decisions. In the documntary on the African
American movement, Eyes on the Prize, there is footage of Coretta Scott King talking about how her husband, Martin Luther King, Jr., saw the federal courts as their ally.

So it is apparently a deeply ingrained belief among civil rights activists that federal court is the place to be.

But that is increasingly not the case for LGBT activists, as the Florida state court decisions indicate. The other, perhaps more compelling example is sodomy laws. The US Supreme Court upheld state sodomy laws in 1986 in Bowers v. Hardwick. During the 1990s, however, a number of state courts struck down their sodomy laws. The 2003 decision in Lawrence v. Texas, which struck down all remaining sodomy statutes, noted the fact of state courts striking the statutes down to support its conlusion.

Similarly, with respect to same-sex marriage, certainly some state courts have issued some impressively stupid rulings, but all of the major victories -- Massachusetts, California -- have come from state courts. Indeed, at the moment, activists are hesitant to bring a marriage suit in federal court because they fear they'll lose.

It's time to rethink the assumption that federal court is always the best place to go for civil rights cases.

No comments:

Post a Comment