Everyone is eager to compare the current financial crisis to the Great Depression. This is badly overblown, and reflects how little most people know about the nation's history. There is perhaps some similarity between the stock market crash of 1929 and the current turmoil in the financial markets, but the key difference is that, in 1929, the Federal Reserve failed to intervene effectively. Some historians argue that there was little the Fed could have done, partly because it was a much more modest entity then, with much more modest powers. Franklin Roosevelt fixed that problem during the 1930s by making the Fed into the entity that we now know and love. There are those who want to eliminate the Federal Reserve. Ron Paul has introduced a bill in Congress that would do exactly that. I don't think we need to worry about that happening any time soon.
But where I think people's ignorance shows through most clearly is with respect to unemployment rates. The rate in the US recently rose to 6.5 percent. This is not a good thing, I don't doubt that life sucks for people who have lost their jobs, and we should do all we can to help them, but that's really quite low by historical standards. During the last recession, in 1992, it hit 7.49. In 1982 it was 9.71. In 1975 it was 8.48. And in 1932, at the nadir of the Great Depresion, it was 25 percent. It is going up, which is a problem, and may indicate future slowing in the economy, but as of now, it's not an impressive number.
This raises the question the Populists used to ask in the late 19th century: just how relevant is Wall Street to the rest of the country? It is possible, after all, that a tanking stock market has little or no impact on business elsewhere. My little brother and father build houses in Oklahoma City, and they don't seem much bothered by the turmoil in the stock markets. It is true that stock ownership is much more widespread among the general population, especially what with 401(k) plans and other retirement vehicles. But the current tanking of the market is only relevant then if you've already retired, or expect to do so soon. Because guess what, no matter how bad it gets now, the markets will recover.
Sunday, November 23, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment