Monday, March 16, 2009

More from Jill Bolte Taylor

Among historians, long quotations are bad form, but I've discovered that bloggers have no such compunctions, so I'm going to follow suit.

Here's more from Jill Bolte Taylor (see previous post) that makes her sound very Buddhist:

This stroke of insight has given me the priceless gift of knowing that deep inner peace is just a thought/feeling away. To experience peace does not mean that your life is always blissful. It means that you are capable of tapping into a blissful state of mind amidst the normal chaos of a hectic life.

This is a very important point. Meditation will not solve all your problems for you. It won't remove the HIV from my body. It has, however, allowed me to respond to my diagnosis as HIV positive and its sequlae with enormous equanimity. Life is much easier when one isn't running around like a chicken with its head cut off, generally making life more difficult for all those around him/her.

Taylor continues:

Based upon my experience with losing my left mind, I whole-heartedly believe that the feeling of deep inner peace is neurological circuitry located in our right brain.

This is an interesting claim -- we are hard-wired for enlightenment. She quotes her "good friend," Dr. Kat Domingo, "Enlightenment is not a process of learning, it is a process of unlearning." Unlearning all our deep-seated habits of left-brain dominance.

This is very Buddhist, whether Taylor recognizes it or not. The word "Buddhism" appears in the book, but only as a passing reference. I plan to write to her on this topic.

Sunday, March 15, 2009

In his book, The Universe in a Single Atom, the Dalai Lama asserts that modern particle physics confirms the Buddhist worldview -- all that we perceive as solid and permanent is actually a swarm of subatomic particles buzzing around.

I thought of this while reading My Stroke of Insight, by Jill Bolte Taylor. Taylor was a brain scientist at Harvard when she had a massive stroke. The book is fascinating. What I find most interesting about it is her description of her experience as the broken blood vessel in the left side of her brain left her with only the right side functioning properly. She says she lost the ability to see boundaries, including the boundaries of her own body, instead perceiving the entire world as boundless energy. She says this was a very seductive perspective, and she had to work to want to restore the funcions of her left brain.

Taylor's description of her experience in her right brain also confirms the Buddhits worldview -- that we are all connected to one another as energy, and our bodily boundaries are mostly an illusion. Taylor makes clear that she was incredibly vulnerable while her right brain was so dominant. She talks about how much impact other people's energy had on her -- for good or ill. This was not nirvana.

Nor would I advocate having a massive stroke in order to experience right-brain dominance. But Buddhism gives us a constructive way to achieve much the same experience -- meditation. It is perhaps a bit of an exaggeration, but not too much of one, to say that the point of meditation is to allow humans to increase their experience of their right brains without destroying their left brains. As someone who was pretty aggressively left-brained before I started meditating -- I had few compunctions about going after people when I thought they were wrong about something, and my facility with language made me very effective -- I am now more balanced, more patient with other people, more compassionate, more relaxed, more equanimous. And, I suppose, happier.

I advocate meditation for everyone. I sometimes wonder how people get through their days without meditating. If you're interested, you might try Sakyong Mipham Rinpoche, Turning the Mind into an Ally. I think the title makes an interesting point -- we might be inclined to think that having a sharp intellect backed up by great verbal facility -- being highly left-brained -- is the best thing to have in this competitive culture, but it's not necessarily. One is actually better off with a balanced brain, with the ability to connect with right-brain functions such as connectedness and compassion.

Friday, March 13, 2009

On same-sex marriage

There is no rational reason to oppose same-sex marriage. This becomes clear when one examines -- or even looks casually at, without right-wing glasses on -- the arguments that right-wingers offer.

The good folks at Focus on the Family assert that "marriage precedes and exceeds the church and the state." Historically, this is simply false -- any history of marriage by a responsible historian will tell you that marriage did not become a sacrament in the Catholic Church -- which was, whether Baptists like it or not, the ONLY church from the period immediately following Jesus' death through the protestant reformation of the 16th century -- until the middle ages. In the United States, marriage has always been a function of the state: you can have all the church weddings you want, but if you don't have a license from the state, you're not legally married.

Let's also think through the implication of this argument: If you believe that marriage precedes and exceeds the church and the state, the obvious inference is that married couples started the state and presumably have some privileged access to the exercise of state power. If one then excludes same-sex couples from marriage, one makes second-class citizens of all lesbians and gay men, as well as all unmarried heterosexuals. But the Constitution, "We the people of the United States of America do hereby ordain and establish," very clearly assumes political participation by all citizens, at least now -- after the Reconstruction Amendments and the Woman Suffrage Amendment. Even before those amendments, looking at the First Amendment, which protects the right of citizens to petition government, makes clear the expectation that all citizens should participate in their government. Note also that the Constitution says nothing about marriage.

Plainly, this right-wing assertion is far outside the constitutional tradition of the United States.

Another group of conservatives, the New Natural Law (NNL) theorists, argue from a more or less explicitly Catholic perspective, although they strive to gussy up their arguments with support from ancient Greek and Roman authorities to escape the obvious objection that our Constitution prohibits establishment of religion. They assert that marriage is a "one-flesh union" an idea that they get from Genesis, the first book of the Bible. On this view, the key thing about marital sex is the union of the two individuals. Children are not the goal -- they "supervene on" married couples who refrain from using contraceptives, which are an absolute no-no. This scheme allows these authors a way to argue that the sex of sterile married couples is moral, whereas any sex that lacks procreative possibility -- whether because of contraceptives, or because of putting parts together in reliably non-reproductive ways -- is inherently immoral. For NNL theorists, all sex by lesbian/gay couples is inherently immoral. Leading NNL theorist John Finnis asserts that the sex of same-sex couples, and deliberately contracepted sex by opposite-sex couples, is as morally worthless as a prostitute's sex with her customer. Catholic constitutional law scholar Michael Perry correctly describes this position as "bizarre."

Catholics have every right to their religious beliefs and practices that follow from those beliefs, but not all of us are Catholic. I'm Buddhist. I do not believe that an omnipotent deity created and controls the universe, or that the Bible is the reveald word of God. And I have, or should have, all the same rights under the United States Constitution as Catholics do, although Finnis makes clear his belief that I should not. So I should not have to adopt an explicitly Catholic understanding of marriage.

Note that this position also provides ample opportunity for coalition-building with heterosexuals who like their contraceptives -- NNL theorists would take those contraceptives away if they had their chance.

I saved the best for last -- my favorite argument against same-sex marriage comes from Maggie Gallagher, because she demonstrates vividly, if inadvertently, that ultimately the argument against same-sex marriage is all about nothing but selfishness. Gallagher has made her mark with the argument that, according to mounds of social-scientific research, marriage is good for people. So she wants to encourage marriage -- but only for heterosexuals. She claims that married people live longer, but does not think same-sex couples should be able to marry. Therefore, she apparently rests content advocating a policy that will shorten the life spans of all lesbians and gay men. I think this is about as reprehensible as one can get. I don't know of anyone else who has pointed out this implication of her position. She should be ashamed.

Madoff suckers

In today's NY Times, Joe Nocera makes an interesting and, I think, underappreciated point under the headline, "Madoff had accomplices: His Victims": Bernie Madoff's "victims" were fools. Nocera makes the key point:

And yet, just about anybody who actually took the time to kick the tires of Mr. Madoff’s operation tended to run in the other direction. James R. Hedges IV, who runs an advisory firm called LJH Global Investments, says that in 1997 he spent two hours asking Mr. Madoff basic questions about his operation. “The explanation of his strategy, the consistency of his returns, the way he withheld information — it was a very clear set of warning signs,” said Mr. Hedges. When you look at the list of Madoff victims, it contains a lot of high-profile names — but almost no serious institutional investors or endowments. They insist on knowing the kind of information Mr. Madoff refused to supply.
In other words, if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is. Do you really need to have a Ph.D. in finance to know how unlikely it is that any investor can really produce highly consistent returns above market averages? Can't be done, sorry.

Nocera quotes at least two of Madoff's "victims" who argue that Congress should create a fund to reimburse them. He then points out that we didn't reimburse the victims of the Enron disaster, or any of the other ponzi schemes that come to light from time to time, so why should we do so for this one? Makes sense to me. These folks broke one of the first rules of investing -- don't put all your eggs in one basket -- same mistake many Enron victims made.

Again, I don't know much about this -- The only stocks I've ever owned I acquired through my TIAA-CREF retirement account. But Nocera's points seem like common sense to me, so I don't have much sympathy for Madoff's "victims."


Thursday, March 12, 2009

Why is anyone a Republican?

Why is anyone a Republican? Since World War II, the Republican Party has mostly held itself out as the source of sound ideas regarding foreign policy and fiscal responsibility. With George W. Bush, they demonstrated how completely they fail on both counts. With respect to foreign policy, numerous governments around the world cheered the end of George W. Bush's heavy=handed, bullying approach, and welcomed Barak Obama's willingness to consult and work with them.

Then, of course, there's the invasion of Iraq. Not only were there no weapons of mass destruction, but from the perspective of American national security, the fact is that we were better off with Sadam Hussein in power than we are with him gone. Note that this argument assumes a sharp divergence between American national security interests and those of the Iraqi people, many of whom undoubtedly suffered horribly under the Hussein regime. But the fact is that Hussein was not an Islamic militant, and he had no patience for others who were. Insofar as the United States currently sees Islamic militants as major sources of terrorism, we were better off when a dictator in Iraq kept Islamic militants there in check. As Mark Mazzetti reported in the NY Times in 2006. "A stark assessment of terrorism trends by American intelligence agencies has found that the American invasion and occupation of Iraq has helped spawn a new generation of Islamic radicalism and that the overall terrorist threat has grown since the Sept. 11 attacks." In sum, the Bush administration achieved exactly the opposite of its stated goal with the invasion of Iraq -- to decrease the threat of terrorism.

In terms of fiscal responsibility, recall that the federal budget was in surplus when Bush took office. We now face enormous deficits for the foreseeable future thanks to Bush's mindless insistence on tax cuts during war time. Cutting taxes during a war is a bizarre choice, grossly irresponsible. A war is a time of national emergency by definition. It is a time for all citizens to contribute to the nation's well-being. I find it profoundly amazing that Bush could get away with such enormous irresponsibility. During World War II, income tax rates rose at their highest from 88% to 94%, and the people who fell under those very high tax rates did not complain, at least not publicly.

These two examples of policy stupidity intersect in Bush's consistent choice to keep the costs of the Iraq war off the formal budget, requesting specific appropriations outside the budget process to pay for it. He believed the invasion of Iraq was necessary for American national security, but wasn't willing to be honest about paying for it.

So we see that, with the Bush administration, the Republican Party has completely lost any reason to exist, given its grotesque failures in the two areas of public policy where it claimed to provide effective leadership.