Why is anyone a Republican? Since World War II, the Republican Party has mostly held itself out as the source of sound ideas regarding foreign policy and fiscal responsibility. With George W. Bush, they demonstrated how completely they fail on both counts. With respect to foreign policy, numerous governments around the world cheered the end of George W. Bush's heavy=handed, bullying approach, and welcomed Barak Obama's willingness to consult and work with them.
Then, of course, there's the invasion of Iraq. Not only were there no weapons of mass destruction, but from the perspective of American national security, the fact is that we were better off with Sadam Hussein in power than we are with him gone. Note that this argument assumes a sharp divergence between American national security interests and those of the Iraqi people, many of whom undoubtedly suffered horribly under the Hussein regime. But the fact is that Hussein was not an Islamic militant, and he had no patience for others who were. Insofar as the United States currently sees Islamic militants as major sources of terrorism, we were better off when a dictator in Iraq kept Islamic militants there in check. As Mark Mazzetti reported in the NY Times in 2006. "A stark assessment of terrorism trends by American intelligence agencies has found that the American invasion and occupation of Iraq has helped spawn a new generation of Islamic radicalism and that the overall terrorist threat has grown since the Sept. 11 attacks." In sum, the Bush administration achieved exactly the opposite of its stated goal with the invasion of Iraq -- to decrease the threat of terrorism.
In terms of fiscal responsibility, recall that the federal budget was in surplus when Bush took office. We now face enormous deficits for the foreseeable future thanks to Bush's mindless insistence on tax cuts during war time. Cutting taxes during a war is a bizarre choice, grossly irresponsible. A war is a time of national emergency by definition. It is a time for all citizens to contribute to the nation's well-being. I find it profoundly amazing that Bush could get away with such enormous irresponsibility. During World War II, income tax rates rose at their highest from 88% to 94%, and the people who fell under those very high tax rates did not complain, at least not publicly.
These two examples of policy stupidity intersect in Bush's consistent choice to keep the costs of the Iraq war off the formal budget, requesting specific appropriations outside the budget process to pay for it. He believed the invasion of Iraq was necessary for American national security, but wasn't willing to be honest about paying for it.
So we see that, with the Bush administration, the Republican Party has completely lost any reason to exist, given its grotesque failures in the two areas of public policy where it claimed to provide effective leadership.
Thursday, March 12, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment