Friday, March 13, 2009

On same-sex marriage

There is no rational reason to oppose same-sex marriage. This becomes clear when one examines -- or even looks casually at, without right-wing glasses on -- the arguments that right-wingers offer.

The good folks at Focus on the Family assert that "marriage precedes and exceeds the church and the state." Historically, this is simply false -- any history of marriage by a responsible historian will tell you that marriage did not become a sacrament in the Catholic Church -- which was, whether Baptists like it or not, the ONLY church from the period immediately following Jesus' death through the protestant reformation of the 16th century -- until the middle ages. In the United States, marriage has always been a function of the state: you can have all the church weddings you want, but if you don't have a license from the state, you're not legally married.

Let's also think through the implication of this argument: If you believe that marriage precedes and exceeds the church and the state, the obvious inference is that married couples started the state and presumably have some privileged access to the exercise of state power. If one then excludes same-sex couples from marriage, one makes second-class citizens of all lesbians and gay men, as well as all unmarried heterosexuals. But the Constitution, "We the people of the United States of America do hereby ordain and establish," very clearly assumes political participation by all citizens, at least now -- after the Reconstruction Amendments and the Woman Suffrage Amendment. Even before those amendments, looking at the First Amendment, which protects the right of citizens to petition government, makes clear the expectation that all citizens should participate in their government. Note also that the Constitution says nothing about marriage.

Plainly, this right-wing assertion is far outside the constitutional tradition of the United States.

Another group of conservatives, the New Natural Law (NNL) theorists, argue from a more or less explicitly Catholic perspective, although they strive to gussy up their arguments with support from ancient Greek and Roman authorities to escape the obvious objection that our Constitution prohibits establishment of religion. They assert that marriage is a "one-flesh union" an idea that they get from Genesis, the first book of the Bible. On this view, the key thing about marital sex is the union of the two individuals. Children are not the goal -- they "supervene on" married couples who refrain from using contraceptives, which are an absolute no-no. This scheme allows these authors a way to argue that the sex of sterile married couples is moral, whereas any sex that lacks procreative possibility -- whether because of contraceptives, or because of putting parts together in reliably non-reproductive ways -- is inherently immoral. For NNL theorists, all sex by lesbian/gay couples is inherently immoral. Leading NNL theorist John Finnis asserts that the sex of same-sex couples, and deliberately contracepted sex by opposite-sex couples, is as morally worthless as a prostitute's sex with her customer. Catholic constitutional law scholar Michael Perry correctly describes this position as "bizarre."

Catholics have every right to their religious beliefs and practices that follow from those beliefs, but not all of us are Catholic. I'm Buddhist. I do not believe that an omnipotent deity created and controls the universe, or that the Bible is the reveald word of God. And I have, or should have, all the same rights under the United States Constitution as Catholics do, although Finnis makes clear his belief that I should not. So I should not have to adopt an explicitly Catholic understanding of marriage.

Note that this position also provides ample opportunity for coalition-building with heterosexuals who like their contraceptives -- NNL theorists would take those contraceptives away if they had their chance.

I saved the best for last -- my favorite argument against same-sex marriage comes from Maggie Gallagher, because she demonstrates vividly, if inadvertently, that ultimately the argument against same-sex marriage is all about nothing but selfishness. Gallagher has made her mark with the argument that, according to mounds of social-scientific research, marriage is good for people. So she wants to encourage marriage -- but only for heterosexuals. She claims that married people live longer, but does not think same-sex couples should be able to marry. Therefore, she apparently rests content advocating a policy that will shorten the life spans of all lesbians and gay men. I think this is about as reprehensible as one can get. I don't know of anyone else who has pointed out this implication of her position. She should be ashamed.

No comments:

Post a Comment